When dusk eventually set in, three more hours had passed. Three more hours that Phineas and his friends had spent collecting their strength for the events to come. Baljeet and Buford had had a lively discussion on the matter of how to defeat the Duke, with brute force or intelligence. Ferb had continued writing into his small book, and Phineas had not wanted to disturb him, so the redhead had been left frustrated that he was not able to invent anything in this world. He was already looking forward to returning home, but now that they were this close to their destination, he was not able to ignore his quite likely fate of death anymore. Not to mention the fact that if Ferb was the one about to die instead, his mother would most likely be witnessing that very moment.
Troubled by thoughts like this, Phineas was incredibly glad that it was finally time for departing. Of course, it would bring them all closer to the threat ahead, but there was no point in delaying their departure - and any kind of occupation was a welcome distraction from worried thoughts.
As Phineas had already expected, Fern was completely assuming control. He was visibly tense, for once not saying much, not even some kind of motivational speech - just a simple »Alright, let’s go« once everyone was ready. And nobody else was saying anything either; because they just wanted to get this all over with, because they didn’t want to break the silence, or because they generally weren’t very talkative. Ferb was one of those people, staying close to his mother as they got moving. And even though he knew he shouldn’t be, Phineas was just the slightest bit jealous again, now that Ferb had someone more important to him than his brother. So Phineas didn’t say anything either.
The silence lasted until the group had walked through the dark tunnels beneath the castle for quite a while and Buford noticed Baljeet’s unusually strained expression.
»Something wrong, nerd?«
Baljeet, much like almost everyone else, flinched as his friend’s loud voice echoed through the tunnels. »I am cogitating on the whereabouts of the darklings«, he informed everyone, considering Buford had completely drawn the attention to him. »We have not seen any of them, even though they are supposed to be especially active at this time of day.«
»Good point«, Bal agreed. Phineas had already noticed during Ferb and Buford’s absence that Baljeet and his look-alike seemed to be getting along quite well, sharing interests and having had a long conversation about an entire span of different topics. »We should at least have heard one by now.«
»It might be a trap«, Fern put in, coming to a halt for now. With a tone that was a little too harsh in Phineas’ opinion, he turned to Finn. »Do you know where they are?«
»...not here«, the boy declined, his voice quiet. Fern must have scared him with his strict voice, and Can gave the green-haired boy an ungentle jab. The boy stared at her, not seeming to know what he did wrong, but then he tried again, forcefully sounding nicer.
»Then where are they?«
»Won't... attack«, Finn stammered, and Phineas pitied him. Fern had made him remember his unpleasant life, and none of them had any experience on how to console him. Thankfully, Izzy took over, and Finn was visibly relieved he was not the center of attention anymore.
»He's right«, she nodded. »The Duke can't talk to the darklings, so they aren't as afraid of him as they used to be. And like I already said, they've always been on our side. The only one we still have to deal with is the Duke himself.«
»Well, that is a relief«, Bal commented, and Phineas believed he heard sarcasm in his voice.
Buford crossed his arms. «That guy's pretty dumb if he allows his only translator to change sides.«
»Unless it is a trap«, Baljeet reminded him, and Bal nodded approvingly. They really shared a lot of opinions.
»Finn wouldn't betray us like that«, Can countered, and Fern stopped them before things escalated.
»What side he's on doesn't matter now. I'm leading this group, we're not going to run into a trap.«
»Unless you're not on our side«, Buford argued. »You know an awful lot about these tunnels, man. How do you explain that, huh?«
Fern frowned. »I already told you, I've been here before, okay? I used to live in this area.«
»There's a village on the other side of the hill«, Can nodded.
Buford made a skeptical sound, but Phineas had enough of that. They were friends, they shouldn't be arguing! Especially not about things like that. »Guys! We're not here to fight. I mean... not against each other! We're a team, and we should act like one. I don't care who's leading the way as long as we get to our destination. If Fern knows which way to go, then let's follow him, alright? Finn can take over once we're in the castle. That way, everyone gets what they want.«
His friends looked at one another, and he saw some of them nodding in approval. And Ferb was glancing amusedly at his brother, in a »Who's the king now?« - way. Phineas blushed; he was only doing his job.
»Thank you, Phineas. Now let's move on.« Fern was visibly bothered by the fact that Phineas was way better at solving conflicts than he was, and he quickly turned away and started walking again, so everyone had to follow him without time for talking.
Once again, there was silence. This time, nobody broke it. Phineas knew that they were all incredibly nervous and irritable, even though technically, their plan was to kill the Duke in his sleep without any complications at all. But they knew that a lot of things could go wrong, and then everything would be different.
Eventually, after some steeper ascension, they reached a dead end, and Buford scoffed. »Great job, o mighty leader.«
Fern shot him an angry glare, then activated some kind of hidden mechanism behind an edge in the rocky formation. At once, the wall swung open, and the flashlight cast its light into a corridor, far longer than the light was reaching on both the left and right side. Directly in front of them was a wall, which meant that this tunnel entrance must have been hidden in a wall as well.
»Now how'd you know that?«, Buford asked in an attempted whisper that was still louder than average.
Fern ignored him. »Your turn, Finn.« He still sounded frustrated, and now even Phineas was convinced that he was hiding something. Had he been a thief before, stealing things from the very castle itself? How else would he be knowing about the hidden passage?
But Phineas didn't say anything. They most definitely had more important things to take care of. And right now, that meant following Finn, who was heading into the left direction. Can and Melody were by his side: the boy was exhausted after this already long walk, and he wouldn't manage to go the remaining distance without someone supporting him. Finn still insisted on not getting carried by Buford; he wanted to prove that he could still do things on his own.
There was an eerie silence now that they were only rooms away from the Duke, only disturbed by the sound of their steps. Fern looked like there was something on his mind, something he desperately wanted to tell everyone but couldn't for some reason. But Finn was still making his way through the dark hallways - until he stopped in front of an enormous door. Fern and Can exchanged glances, as if they knew something about this place. As if this was the completely wrong place to go. Melody seemed nervous too, and Fern looked very reluctant when he gave his approval for opening the door.
Buford pushed it open, and it seemed to be heavy even for him. He let everyone through and closed it behind them.
Fern let the flashlight wander across the room. It was huge; the light did not reach the other end. Slowly, he moved the light around, and there was nothing to see but an empty hall. Eventually, the light found a chair, a throne even. It wasn't empty, but occupied by a man in a dark robe, with a triangular head and a pointy nose, and long brown hair that was tied together.
With eyes that could kill, and a wide, wicked grin, he was staring directly at them.
Fern dropped the flashlight, and it turned off. And for one moment, it was completely dark. They were all far too shocked and scared to move or speak, and not a single sound was heard - save for the man's cackling laughter echoing from the walls.
Phineas was unable to do anything. He couldn't even see his own hand, and this man could be everywhere now. He could kill them all before they even knew he was there.
Thankfully, this terrifying moment was quickly over. The man muttered something, and suddenly, several torches all across the room lit up. Phineas shut his eyes in the sudden brightness, but quickly adjusted himself. Now he could see the entirety of the wide and high room, decorated with numerous pillars, but otherwise empty - not including the man and his enormous throne.
Albeit useless, everyone drew their weapon, Melody and Brain growled, Bal stood protectively in front of Bue, same for Buford and Baljeet - and Finn fell to his knees, lowering his head so deeply that his face almost touched the ground. His remaining eye was closed, his body shaking - partly from his fear, and partly from straining his one remaining arm. And the man spoke.
»Well done, my boy. It pleases me to see that you have carried out my orders as instructed.« He had a high, raspy voice, but the calmness in it made him all the more terrifying.
Phineas gulped. They had all felt the trap on their way, and still, they had marched right into it. And Finn had known all along, without saying a word - while Izzy, who had explicitly told them of the very high probability of Finn going to betray them, had been ignored completely. But that’s what they got for that: an actual conversation with the Duke himself.
»Let him go!«, Can yelled at the man on the throne, completely ignoring every danger. She had enough of him, and especially of seeing her own brother treated like this.
The man did not lose his spiteful smile as he turned his head to her. And worse, he also kept his calm tone. »And why would I do that? You and I both know that he is rather… valuable.«
»Nobody deserves to be treated this way«, Can replied; her angry and upset voice was the complete opposite of the Duke’s. »He should be with his family, where he belongs.«
The Duke cackled again. »Dead like his father, or gone like his mother? Or with his sister who never bothered looking for him - even though the entire time, he had always been right here in these tunnels?«
Can froze at this last comment, and Phineas could completely relate. Realizing that all this time, Finn had been so close to her…
Now that Can was still processing the Duke’s words, the man spoke to Fern. »Anyway… I must say, I am quite impressed that you actually made it. Didn’t expect you to come back here anytime soon.« Bal raised an eyebrow at that, and some others, including Phineas, agreed. Back here? Have they met before, in this very castle?
»We have come to vanquish you, Doonkleberg. Following a prophecy, your demise has arrived at last.« Was that the man’s actual name? So they did know each other.
The man leaned forward. »Tell me about that prophecy of yours.«
Fern didn’t see why not, so he complied. »It tells of two brothers from another world defeating you, and the time for that has come.«
The Duke seemed unmoved by these words. Even slightly amused. »And where is it from?«
»A wise and reliable member of the resistance.«
Now, the man actually started laughing. »Oh, I see what they did there! Kid, you’ve been fooled. I mean, come on: the Great Evil destroyed when all hope is lost? And even better, by mysterious and vaguely described strangers? They made it up.«
»He wouldn’t«, Fern replied behind clenched teeth, and the Duke shrugged.
»I’m sure he would. We both know that you’ve done everything in your power to avoid all kinds of responsibility your entire life. If he knows, too, then a prophecy stating someone but you would defeat me in the end is everything you ever wanted to hear.«
»What is he talking about?«, Bal asked his leader. Phineas knew how much he looked up to Fern, how much he trusted him… a secret was to be uncovered, and the redhead and Bal both sensed that it was something big.
The Duke seemed to notice Bal’s relationship to Fern as well. »Did you never even tell them your name?« He sounded shocked - although it was plain to see how he had already expected it, and that he was just messing with them.
»Nobody is forced to tell anyone their full name in the resistance«, Fern replied, determined not to reveal anything.
»Balavan Tinley.« Bal’s voice was cold. Fern was keeping something from him, from all of them - and if it was this serious, it was breaking Bal’s trust.
»Oh snap«, Buford mumbled, and all eyes were on Fern. He was still hesitating, but even Can prompted him now.
»Just tell them already, Fern.«
The boy eventually gave in, trying to sound confident, but actually failing at that for once. »Fernando Alexander Fleming.«
Was that supposed to mean something? That name did not tell Phineas anything, and he saw that his friends from his own dimension were equally clueless. Unlike Bal.
His eyes widened in horror, and to make it worse, the Duke used his powers to telekinetically turn something around: a huge canvas from behind his throne that had faced the wall until now. And looking at its now revealed front side, Phineas realized what was so special about Fern’s name.
Because on this canvas was a portrait - of a younger Fern who was holding the same sword he still owned, but without being able to actually lift it at that age, and a man bearing a striking resemblance to Lawrence, Ferb’s father. Looking at the viewer. And dressed in royal clothes.
Bal stared at Fern in complete disbelief. »He…«
Phineas remembered what Bal had told him: the king that had fled the country in fear of the Duke. The king that had abandoned an entire country. The king that had made Bal lose all respect for royalty.
»...is my father, yeah.« Fern actually sounded ashamed, but that didn’t change Bal’s thoughts.
»I cannot believe you kept that from me!«, he yelled, his voice sounding higher than usual as he did that, just like Baljeet when he was frustrated. »You are the prince . The one that was supposed to defend the country. And what did you do? Run away, just like your father. How can I trust you now, knowing that you are one of them? You and your father, you could have prevented this from happening. All of it.«
»Oh, but so could you, Balavan.« The Duke really seemed to enjoy the argument he had ignited. And now, its feeble spark was about to turn into a mighty blaze. »Remember this?« The man revealed the necklace he was wearing: a simple cord, with a silver-blue-ish gemstone attached to it. The stone seemed to be glowing faintly, and Phineas realized this must be the source of his powers.
Bal looked at it from the distance. He was still overwhelmed by the current events, and yet again couldn’t believe his eyes. His words were forced. »...that stone belongs to my parents.« They were merchants, Phineas remembered. Or had been, anyway.
»It did, once«, the Duke corrected him. »Somebody stole it from them, remember?«
»...no«, Bal whispered. He had realized something, remembered something, and the Duke made sure that everyone else knew about it as well.
»Yes. I was the man you saw talking to them that one night. You caught me stealing this very stone when I left, and detested your parents so much that you didn’t say a word. If only you had spoken up about it… I would never have gotten away with this stone, the source of my powers. Blame your weak excuse for a leader all you want - but let’s face the facts: added to your heartwarming act of abandoning an entire village, including your family, for one unimportant boy, you are completely to blame for all the misfortune I was able to cause with this wonderful little stone.« He mocked Bal by repeating the boy’s own words. »You could have prevented this from happening. All of it.«
The sum of all this was simply too much for Bal to handle. Before things escalated and he broke down in tears, or worse, he dashed out of the room. Bue, unsure about what to do, looked around, then decided to follow his best friend. And nobody stopped him.
»And then there were eight«, the Duke commented. »And… Your Highness«, he said to Fern, very aware of how much that hit him, »I highly appreciate your return and the company you have brought. But understand, I am only in need of one of you.« And the man looked directly at Phineas.
Don’t show any kind of weakness, Phineas reminded himself. »What do you want from me?«
»The same thing I wanted from your father«, the Duke shrugged. »A gateway to your dimension.«
»I’m not going to help you with that«, Phineas declined immediately, his thoughts centering on his long-lost father. He didn't give in. So I won't either.
»Thought so. Luckily, I can be very convincing.« And with that, the Duke put one hand on his necklace and pointed the other one at Phineas. Suddenly, the boy felt pain spreading across his body. As if a million scorching suns were bursting inside of him. He fell to his knees, screaming as the pain became almost unbearable. Ferb was trying to get to him, but the others held him back, and just when Phineas thought he’d be dead any second now, the pain was gone. Weakened by this experience, and shaking still, he fell to the ground, only faintly hearing the Duke’s words - »I’ll give you some time to reconsider« - before passing out.
---
Ferb helplessly watched the scene playing out in front of him. He wanted to help his brother, more than anything else, but his friends were holding him back. Even if all he could do was share Phineas’ pain or feel it instead of him, he had to do something. But then, Phineas was already on the ground. Trembling... unconscious.
And the Duke really seemed to take pleasure in the shocked expressions of the group. »Finn«, he commanded, and the boy rapidly stood up, still with balance problems. »Take him away.«
Finn bowed his head once more, then growled. Melody snarled back angrily, and Ferb looked at her with worry in his eyes. Was Finn trying to give her orders? The boy continued with insistence, and albeit hesitantly, she eventually complied. The darkling walked over to Phineas, gently picking him up. She gazed at Ferb, and the determination in her eyes was still there. She’d do everything in her power to protect Phineas, Ferb understood, and that helped him get over attempting to save his brother right now… at least somewhat. He shot a glare to his friends, stopping them from doing anything imprudent. With Phineas on Melody’s back, she and Finn left the room, and the Duke was still wearing his grin.
»And then there were six. Don’t worry, I’m not planning to reveal any other shocking backstories anytime soon… but I’m not done with you yet.«
»What do you even want?«, Buford put in, unable to keep his mouth shut any longer. »The dogs, the magic, some vague relations to practically everyone, and your weird obsession with people with triangular heads… what’s your point, man?«
From what he could tell, Ferb shared Baljeet’s thoughts: Just great, Buford. As if we didn’t have enough problems already. But the Duke was not enraged at all. Instead, he seemed… happy. Happy that he could tell everyone about his evil scheme. And admittedly, Ferb was also quite interested in how it all fit together.
»Well, kid, you see«, the man began. »It all started in a country not too far away from this one. I’m not going into detail here, but the precis is: everyone I knew was achieving something great in life - royalty, popularity, all those things I lacked. So I did the most logical thing… I came here and killed the king in order to spread chaos. Then I withdrew as soon as I realized that taking over wouldn’t be all that easy - while taking his son with me, an actual human I could bend to my will… quite a tempting thought, no?« The man enjoyed the shocked, and in Can’s case, angry expressions of his enemies. »In the same night, I met a stranger from another dimension, he said. That guy’s imagination sounded quite useful at the time, so made him join me and then turned against him and kept him prisoner for the time being. And how’d you know - just two years later, I found a woman he actually knew from his world, and she apparently was a pretty good tinkerer. I imprisoned her as well and forced the two of them to devise powerful gadgets for me to use.«
Phineas’ father… and my mother. They really had known each other.
»Point is, another king came, and with him a merchant family I got this little gem from.« He held up his necklace again. »I don’t know if it really is any kind of magical, but with the modifications my new friends made… I can do just about anything with it. My favorite option is turning people into what everyone calls darklings - they cost less than soldiers, obey more easily, and the only downside is their unintelligible language. But I’ve got Finn to take care of that, so never mind.
»And, well, I’m sure you know most of the rest. How I took over this entire place, scared the coward of a king back to where he had come from… and once that was done, I started waiting for your little friend. His father had become quite useless for me for one reason or another, and the woman wasn’t good for anything other than darkling-ness without him. To get to their home dimension, and take over it, of course, I needed someone with an equally inventive mind, something I was certain to find in the son he had talked about.
»So, yes, all this time, I could have destroyed the resistance, I mean, I did know of it. But I let it be - because ultimately, I needed you to bring Josh’s son here. Of course, there was a chance of him not showing up at all, but you know what they say. Like father, like son.« The Duke looked at Fern as he said that, and the boy did his best to appear unmoved. The revelation about his family tree had surprised Ferb as well, but he considered it too early to judge him yet. As for the Duke, Ferb did not know what to think of him either. He seemed like a megalomaniac, a madman even, but with an unsettling patience. Which made him all the more dangerous.
And suddenly, Ferb was absolutely positive that there was only one way to defeat the Duke with all his magic, knowledge, and power. A seemingly utterly foolish thought - but there was no other possibility.
He took a step forward.
»Doonkleberg«, he announced, determined to sound absolutely convinced of his own abilities. »I challenge you to a duel.«
For a moment, nobody said anything. Until Buford did.
»Are you crazy, man? That’s, like, such a bad idea.«
But he had caught the Duke’s attention, and the man leaned forward curiously. »I am sure he is familiar with the rules.«
Ferb nodded. He knew the traditional rules of dueling, he had read about it in several medieval books - including the tale of King Arthur. »One-on-one, with no restrictions regarding weapons or techniques, as long as they are compatible with the code of honor.«
»Fine, I’ll make an exception for you on the last part«, the Duke replied, but overall agreed with what Ferb had said. Then, he brought up another question. »At what price?«
Ferb had already expected that question, and his answer was simple. A high price, but a just one. »If the resistance wins, you will release all prisoners, turn the darklings back into humans, and leave the country without ever returning.«
The Duke grinned. »And if I win?«
Ferb took a deep breath. He was well aware of what was at stake, but he had to give the Duke a convincing reason to accept. There was no turning back. He could save Phineas, his mother, and both dimensions… he had no other choice. »Then my dimension and I will be at your command.«
Behind him, Baljeet gasped audibly, and Ferb couldn’t blame him. To everyone else, his proposal must be sounding completely foolish - maybe it was, but it was the only thing he could do.
And the Duke… well, he sounded pleased. »We have a deal.«
»Tomorrow, at noon«, Ferb declared, forcing himself to sound confident. In truth, he was still incredibly nervous, but the Duke would only take pleasure in seeing him like that. And the boy knew that a good first impression could already determine a lot. He did not want the Duke to believe that he was afraid and intimidated. »Until then, you will allow us to remain in the castle without being threatened by your side. A truce, per se.« That was nothing far-fetched; a cease-fire before the arranged date of the duel was only fair.
»You have my word«, the Duke nodded.
»Will you keep it?«
»If you keep yours.«
Ferb nodded. »High noon«, he repeated. He detested the Duke, but respected him nevertheless, so he bowed his head, turned around, and left the room with his head lifted high.
But without being able to look any of his friends into the eyes.